cream of the crate cd review #22 – the great eric clapton and the yardbirds [box set]
cream of the crate cd review #22 – the great eric clapton and the yardbirds [box set]
Box Set – [CL:ICK to enlarge]


  This review was originally posted on the first Toorak Times web site where publications ceased on that site in March 2017. The old site will be permanently closed in 2020 and these reviews are being re-published in order to preserve them on the current Toorak Times/Tagg site.


"If you hand me a guitar, I'll play the blues. That's the place I automatically go." - (Eric Clapton)

Cream Of The Crate Reviews 1 to 50 were vinyl album reviews.  
The following fifty reviews (51 - 100) were originally marked as CD Reviews 1 - 50
and this numbering has been kept to keep consistency with the published CD reviews.


This is number twenty two in the series of retro-reviews of Cd albums in my collection.

The series is called, “Cream of The Crate (CD’s)”, and they represent CD albums that I believe are of significant musical value, either because of their rarity, because they represent the best of a style or styles of music or because there is something unique about the group or the music.

With the review of CD #22 I find myself drawn toward a 3CD Set, that has so little going for it in terms of an accompanying booklet, but as a “set” of music it must, and does, have something very special.

The set titled “The Great Eric Clapton and the Yardbirds” was bought out on the RED label (RED032) in 2000.

cream of the crate cd review #22 – the great eric clapton and the yardbirds [box set]
CD Label – [CLICK to enlarge]


Adding to its desirability, is the fact that along with Clapton came a group of musicians that together formed the Yardbirds and who, for a brief but powerful time, ruled the electric blues airwaves.

It’s a release by the Rajon Music Group and is presented as a limited edition 3-CD set, and comes in a well made die-cut blue slip-in box with embossed gold labelling that looks the goods.

However, there is no booklet, not even a folded insert and that, does take the edge of it being a quality production and really, there is no excuse for it and I cannot imagine the reasoning behind the omission of this important supplementary piece.

cream of the crate cd review #22 – the great eric clapton and the yardbirds [box set]
Disc 1 Cover – [CLICK to enlarge]
 Almost 20 years have passed since its release but given Eric has been entertaining us over a six decade period, that’s almost a drop in the bucket!

It is an all-round reminder of a music playing genius (who had his with flaws) and a group, which were idolised back in the 1960’s.

Eric Clapton is now in my mind and the minds of many others as, an absolute living legend.

Born in March 1945, at the age of 16 he was busking and at 17 he was playing in small pubs with fellow blues enthusiast David Brock.

Also at 17 he joined an early R&B group based around Surrey, called “The Roosters” and then in 1963 he joined the well loved group, the Yardbirds.

cream of the crate cd review #22 – the great eric clapton and the yardbirds [box set]
Clapton with The Roosters


It was in the Yardbirds that he began to become not just appreciated, but to be “worshiped” for his guitar work.

Clapton was initially pleased with the Yardbirds as their repertoire was almost entirely blues based.

In 1965 the Yardbirds had their first hit with “For Your Love“, which Clapton played on. However he was most upset at this change of direction into the more ‘pop’ side of music.

Clapton then eagerly accepted an invitation and joined John Mayall & the Bluesbreakers in April 1965.

There was a period when he left the Bluebreakers and joined some friends in a group called “The Glands“, but again after a few months he left them to rejoin and have a second stint with the Bluesbreakers.

cream of the crate cd review #22 – the great eric clapton and the yardbirds [box set]
[CLICK to enlarge]


This was the style of music he wanted and at this time he swapped his Fender Telly and Vox amp for a Les Paul and a Marshall amp. I

cream of the crate cd review #22 – the great eric clapton and the yardbirds [box set]
[CLICK to enlarge]
 It wasn’t long after that and largely due to his style of playing and the resulting sound, that he started being called “god” through the caption, “Clapton is God”, which appeared on walls everywhere.

He then became an integral part of a magnificent three-piece group, The Cream.

With this move came a degree of contentment and some most excellent music, but the Cream had a “use by date”, and he found it necessary to move on.

Certainly over the years he has always either moved directly back to the blues or certainly has integrated elements into his own music. However, for the purposes of this review I am staying with the period he was with the Yardbirds, particularly the earlier period when the group was a solid electric blues band.

The earliest version of the band formed in the London suburbs in the early 1960s and were known as “The Metropolis Blues Quartet“.

By 1963, the Yardbirds line-up had gelled with core members Keith Relf (vocals, harmonica), Chris Dreja (rhythm guitar), Paul Samwell-Smith (bass) and Jim McCarty (drums), in addition to lead guitarist Anthony “Top” Topham.

When sixteen-year-old Topham was pressured by his parents to quit, Eric Clapton, stepped in. In regard to the name change, in late May 1963, they decided to change it and after a couple of gigs in September 1963 as the Blue-Sounds.

It was then they settled on the Yardbirds, which was both an expression for hobos hanging around rail yards waiting for a train and also a reference to the jazz saxophonist Charlie “Yardbird” Parker.

Now it was about the time that Clapton joined the group that their big break came.

The Rolling Stones had a residency at the famous Crawdaddy Club in Surrey, but their fame was growing and it was time for them to move on, and the Yardbirds got the gig.

The Crawdady Club was being run by Giorgio Gomelski, and he became both the bands Manager, and their first Producer.

Left to right – McCarty, Samwell-Smith, Clapton, Relf & Dreja


So, to the music in this set. What this boxed set does provide is a most excellent selection of blues material from that fantastic period.

Track Selection

Disc 1:
  1. I Wish You Would
  2. A Certain Girl
  3. Good Morning Little Schoolgirl
  4. I Ain’t Got You
  5. For Your Love
  6. Got To Hurry
  7. Heart Full Of Soul
  8. Steeled Blues
  9. Evil Hearted You
  10. Still I’m Sad
  11. Shapes Of Things
  12. Mister, You’re A Better Man Than I
  13. I’m A Man
  14. New York City Blues
Disc 2:
  1. Train Kept A-Rollin’
  2. Paff … Bum
  3. Mr Zero
  4. Sweet Music
  5. Someone To Love Parts 1 & 2
  6. Stroll On
  7. Too Much Monkey Business
  8. Got Love If You Want
  9. Smokestack Lightning
  10. Five Long Years
  11. Louise
  12. Baby, What’s Wrong
  13. Boom, Boom
Disc 3:
  1. Honey In Your Hips
  2. Talkin’ ‘Bout You
  3. Let It Rock
  4. Take It Easy Baby
  5. Highway 69
  6. Putty (In Your Hands)
  7. I’m Not Talking
  8. I Ain’t Done Wrong
  9. My Girl Sloopy
  10. Jeff’s Blues
  11. Like Jimmy Reed Again
  12. What Did You Want
  13. Here ‘Tis

We are presented forty tracks that include the two singles “I Wish You Would” and “Good Morning Little Schoolgirl“.

However, it was their 3rd single that eventually drove Clapton out of the group – that being the Graham Gould’s (10cc) composition, For Your Love.

What becomes quite apparent is that the producers of this CD have highlighted that it is Eric Clapton & the Yardbirds, but there are a number of commercial tracks included, the best known one’s cut after Clapton left.

It is here we find either Jimmy Page or Jeff Beck playing guitar.

Incidentally, there appears to be no rhyme or reason for the track order.

I’m going to stick to the tracks that Clapton played on, especially the blues based material, of which there is much to choose from.


As both singles “I Wish You Would” and “Good Morning Little Schoolgirl” are on CD #1 it seemed to make sense to feature these.

(Come back baby) I Wish You Would, was written and performed by Billie Boy Arnold, who happens to be a favourite of mine, and Arnolds’ version is certainly the yard measure for the many versions recorded by many artists. When the Yardbirds recorded and released this version it flopped.

This was both surprising and yet, understandable.

It was their debut single and released in 1964 it would have been a hit IF the buying audience was the same audience that loved the group live. It wasn’t!

The track is a ‘Chicago Blues Classic’ and it is so obvious why the Yardies chose it, as it has a good uptempo beat and plenty of room for wailing harmonica.

Unfortunately as well played as the harp is, it takes all the focus and there is little of Clapton’s brilliance shining through.

Early in the morning about the break of day
That’s when my baby went away
Crying and pleading won’t do you no good
Come back baby I wish you would

I Wish You Would


Good Morning Little Schoolgirl is another “Chicago Blues Classic”.

Written and recorded prior to WWII by Sonny Boy Williamson II, it’s another blues track that was to end up in the repertoire of almost all blues based bands, worldwide.

So it is no surprise that the blues crazy Clapton would want it on the groups play list and in doing so, he joined many other greats such as John Lee Hooker, Lightnin’ Hopkins, Mississippi Fred McDowell, Muddy Waters and Doctor Ross.

It’s a fantastic uptempo electric blues piece and while it did not reach any giddy heights, it was appreciated more by the public and rose to #44 on the British charts, staying there for 4 weeks.

The Yardbirds certainly put more of a ‘stamp’ on this track than they did with I Wish You Would. It is set at a faster pace than most other versions and while it retains elements of blues, it is certainly delivered in a more conventional ‘pop’ delivery style.

What is pleasing is that there are some delightful guitar pieces from Clapton, and to be honest, I think Keith Relfs delivery is better on this track than that first release.

Listening to this track does give you some idea of the music that was flooding across Britain as the Yardbirds, along with the Animals, Stones and Pretty Things all were going hell bent in the clubs and pubs taking the American Blues tracks, and massaging and shaping them into what would be called the “British Sound”.

Good Morning Little Schoolgirl



Track # 9 is Smokestack Lightning which was recorded by and made famous by, Howling Wolf.

That the group would choose this track to put on their play list is of no surprise. It is a fantastic track and has been covered by so many groups, too many to list.

Smokestack Lightning” received a Grammy Hall of Fame Award in 1999 honoring its lasting historical significance and was #291 in Rolling Stones list of the “500 Greatest Songs of All Time.

The song takes the form of “a propulsive, one-chord vamp, nominally in E major but with the flatted blue notes that make it sound like E minor”, but this very basic structure hides the the true success of the track.

The energy that it creates and the success of it can often be measured in terms of the vocal delivery. Relf is a little under-powered to truly do the song justice, but the harp playing is good, the bass/drum combo is very good and while Clapton is somewhat in the background it is an excellent example of British based blues.

Smokestack Lightning

The final track on this Cd is Boom Boom

Boom Boom is yet another blues classic covered by the Yardies.

Originally recorded by John Lee Hooker it was originally recorded at an amazing 168 beats per minute, which is quite a driving pace for a blues track.

It was only released a couple of years before Clapton joined the Yardbirds (1962 in fact), so it would have been almost on their lips when they were putting their playlist together.

A great live performance track, it was unlikely to ever have been released as a single given the Animals did that in 1964 and had a modest hit from their effort.

Yet in all honesty, the version by the Yardbirds is superior to the Animals with maybe the exception of Eric Burden’s delivery being better than Keith relf.

However, I do think Relf made a damn fine effort on this one, and his harp playing excels again. Clapton is a bit more forward in this track and breaks out with some classic Clapton licks and his sound? It’s like liquid silver.
Boom, boom, boom, boom
I’m gonna shoot you right down
Right off your feet
Take you home with me
Put you in my house
Boom, boom, boom, boom

Boom Boom



Track #1Honey In Your Hips is one fantastic track by the Yardies.

It was released in the Netherlands and Germany on a single, along with Boom Boom, but released after Clapton had left the Yardbirds.

Written by Keith Relf it does suggest that if Clapton was still wanting to be steeped in the Blues, that maybe Relf was looking for a way out into a different direction.

The track is an uptempo blues track, but it certainly does make an attempt at being more a pop track. Relf’s harp and Clapton’s guitar certainly keep it within the Blues idiom, but the end was near.

When I get out on the dancing floor
There ain’t no stopping for an hour or more
I go rocking up and down and around and round
I go reeling to the beat of that crazy sound
I can’t stop, I want to kiss your pretty lips
‘Cause I know, pretty babe, you got honey in your hips

I can’t stop my feet and I can’t stop my hands
When I hear the sound of a rock ‘n’ roll band
Gotta rock, gotta roll, gonna jump and shout
Nobody better come and turn me out
I’m staying all night ’til I get my kicks
‘Cause you know, pretty babe, you got honey in your hips

I want you and you want me
We’re gonna dance all night ’til we both feel free
We’ll shake and we’ll shimmy right across the floor
When it gets late, we’ll dance out the door
You better get ready with your pretty lips
‘Cause you know, pretty babe, you got honey in your hips

Honey In Your Hips


The final track pays homage to the playing of Clapton and the Yardbirds in those ‘heady’ blues days, but it also plays equal homage to the original blues masters.

When the Yardbirds with Clapton were joined by none other than Sonny Boy Williamson II then they hit a peak! 

The recording demonstrates the quality playing of the Yardies, all of them, and how when they have a true ‘blues master’ at the mic, they would pass any audition anywhere as a top blues band.

The track is #4 – Take It Easy Baby.

They did!  This is really relaxed, take it easy blues. It was recorded in England at the Crawdaddy Club in Richmond, Surrey on December 8, 1963.

This is a lay-back blues track as good as it can get from a white band and so it should, because on vocals is nom other than Sonny Boy Williamson II.

The question has often been asked, “Can White Men sing the blues?” – well on this track, Clapton shows a white man sure can play the blues!

Take It Easy Baby

If we listen to recent Eric Clapton and then we listen to set of CD’s representing his very early work, we can only come to one conclusion.

Clapton’s first and foremost love is the blues! His guitar playing has vacillated from the pure unadulterated brilliance through to that of a smacked out addict only return like an excellently vintage wine!

The legacy he is developing will see him remembered as a a gifted musician; guitar genius, composer and singer who overcame his ‘demons’.

This is a fine set of music from those early years, and whilst not by any means the only compilation of those early years, it is an excellent one.

It is boxed very nicely, yet not costing an arm or a leg when released.

I checked around on Ebay and found a single boxed set for about Au$68.00 inc postage.

Just keep the name in the back of your mind, because if you do come across the complete set, buy it!


Once again YouTube came through with some very worthwhile clips of Clapton playing with the Yardbirds, and these very appropriately supplement the discussions above.


For Your Love




Early Years with Eric Clapton